McDonald's Menu Prices at 500 N Main St ★2.5 (113)

500 N Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344

Photos & Reviews

📍 See all on Google Maps → Powered by Google
McDonald's store photo
McDonald's store photo
McDonald's store photo
McDonald's store photo
McDonald's store photo
Mr. Review a month ago
★★☆☆☆

The reviews are pretty much right! Got breakfast bagels they were pretty much at bottom of the barrel taste wise. They changed the sauce I believe too. The big breakfast we got was lacking the big part. This was a to go order and you barely interact with anyone but they forgot the straws one of the most important items next to getting the food right. The prices just keep getting higher while the quality goes down. Overall to sum it up honestly it sucked! They just opened in Fall of 2025 you think they wouldn't be better. 2.5 starts currently in Jan. 2026 The owners need to read reviews!

Slim Nice a week ago
★★★★★

Just placed an order for our shop and the staff took my list of everyone's order and filled the order by putting each ones order in a bag with their name on and everything was done perfectly and the staff here is awesome. Our favorite McDonald's for breakfast is in New Carlisle Ohio. A shout out for perfection.

Otis B a year ago
★☆☆☆☆

Nobody in the drive-thru and nobody in the lobby and it still took over 15 minutes to get food. Actually had to ask the manager how much longer it was going to be and even she was rude as hell. Food came out slopped together. Had to wrap it with a napkin just to eat it because it was so bad. Every table in the place was dirty.. If there's no customers, how is there no time to clean the tables? If this is a standard, I can see why there was no one there.

Captured by LeVeck 2 months ago
★☆☆☆☆

Employee didnt want to take our classic big mac pack order saying it had to be a mobile order for them to do it even though every other mcdonalds I've been to they had no problem doing it. Lazy employees get lazy reviews.

Stephanie Crosby 6 months ago
★☆☆☆☆

No one is upfront to greet you. We had to wait over 20 min for our order. Two meals and a Happy Meal. No one apologized for the wait. I had to stand at the counter looking back at the prep area to even get someone to look in our direction.

ZIP 45344 New Carlisle Ohio ☁️ 48°F · Partly Cloudy · Oct 27

McDonald's Menu with Prices at This Location

How It Compares

This location
500 N Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344
$5.29
New Carlisle avg
Across 1 locations
$5.29
Ohio avg
Across 843 locations
$5.09
US National avg
All tracked US neighborhoods
$5.91

Nearby McDonald's Locations Within 5 Miles

After You Eat — What's Nearby?

🗺️

After enjoying a meal at McDonald's, explore a variety of attractions that cater to all interests, from nature preserves to military history. There are engaging parks, museums, and entertainment centers that make for great family outings or individual adventures.

🌟 all
National Museum of the U.S. Air Force
This museum showcases a vast collection of aircraft and artifacts, detailing the history of aviation and the Air Force. It's a must-visit for anyone interested in military history and aviation.
🌟 families|couples
Charleston Falls Preserve
A beautiful nature preserve featuring a 37-foot waterfall, scenic hiking trails, and diverse wildlife, perfect for nature lovers and families alike.
🌟 families|all
Brukner Nature Center
This center offers wildlife exhibits, hiking trails, and educational programs about local flora and fauna, providing a rich experience for nature enthusiasts.
🌟 all
John Bryan State Park
A state park featuring beautiful hiking trails, rock climbing opportunities, and scenic views of the Little Miami River gorge, ideal for outdoor enthusiasts.
👨‍👩‍👧 families
Smith Park
A local park featuring playgrounds, walking trails, and picnic areas, perfect for leisurely strolls or family fun.
🌟 families|couples
Wegerzyn Gardens MetroPark
A botanical garden featuring formal gardens, a children's discovery garden, and beautiful walking trails, great for family outings and nature walks.
🌟 families|all
Englewood MetroPark
This park offers hiking trails, waterfalls, and opportunities for fishing and birdwatching, making it a delightful escape into nature.
👨‍👩‍👧 families
Aullwood Audubon Center and Farm
An environmental education center with nature trails, farm animals, and interactive exhibits, suitable for families seeking educational fun.
🌟 young adults|families
The Greene Town Center
An open-air shopping center featuring a variety of retail stores, restaurants, and a movie theater, perfect for a day of shopping and leisure.
🌟 all
Dayton Art Institute
An art museum showcasing a diverse collection of artworks, from ancient to contemporary pieces, ideal for art lovers and cultural enthusiasts.
🌟 families|couples
SunWatch Indian Village Archaeological Park
A reconstructed Native American village offering insights into the area's indigenous history, perfect for history buffs and families.
👨‍👩‍👧 families
Young's Jersey Dairy
A family-friendly farm offering delicious ice cream, mini-golf, batting cages, and animal interactions, a hit with kids and adults alike.
🌟 young adults|couples
Rose Music Center at The Heights
An outdoor amphitheater hosting concerts and events during the warmer months, great for music lovers looking for an evening out.
🌟 families|young adults
Scene75 Entertainment Center
A large indoor entertainment complex offering go-karts, laser tag, arcade games, and more, perfect for fun-seekers of all ages.
🌟 all
Huffman Prairie Flying Field
A historic site where the Wright brothers perfected their flying techniques, with interpretive displays and walking trails for history enthusiasts.
👨‍👩‍👧 families
Carriage Hill MetroPark
A historical farm and park offering hiking trails and fishing ponds, providing a glimpse into 19th-century farm life for visitors.
🌟 all
New Carlisle Public Library
A community hub with a vast collection of books, media, and regular events, inviting visitors of all ages to engage with literature.
🌟 young adults|all
New Carlisle Sports and Fitness Center
A local gym offering fitness classes, weightlifting, and cardio equipment for those looking to keep fit and healthy.
🧑 young adults
Yellow Springs Brewery
A craft brewery offering a variety of beers and a relaxed atmosphere, popular among young adults looking to unwind.
🌟 families|couples
Clifton Mill
A historic grist mill known for its beautiful setting and holiday light displays, offering tours and a restaurant for visitors.

McDonald's 500 N Main St — Frequently Asked Questions

McDonald's menu prices at 500 N Main St, New Carlisle OH in 2026
The McDonald's menu at 500 N Main St in New Carlisle, OH currently lists Big Mac at $5.29, Medium Fries at $3.19, and 20-piece Chicken McNuggets at $7.79. This store is also showing limited-time items including Derpy McFlurry at $4.99, Ramyeon McShaker Fries at $3.69, Saja Boys Breakfast Meal at $8.79. Every menu item on this page is pulled from the McDonald's app for this specific location and last verified October 2026.
How much is a Big Mac at McDonald's at 500 N Main St?
A Big Mac at the McDonald's at 500 N Main St in New Carlisle, OH is $5.29 as of October 2026. The New Carlisle city average is $5.29 and the US national average is $5.91. This store is at or below the national average.
McDonald's fries price at 500 N Main St in New Carlisle
Medium French Fries at the McDonald's at 500 N Main St in New Carlisle, OH are $3.19 as of October 2026. See how this compares to other New Carlisle stores on our city page.
McNuggets price on the McDonald's menu at 500 N Main St
20-piece Chicken McNuggets at the McDonald's at 500 N Main St in New Carlisle, OH cost $7.79 as of October 2026. Compare McNuggets prices at other New Carlisle stores on our city page.
Is the limited-time Derpy McFlurry available at McDonald's at 500 N Main St?
Yes. The limited-time Derpy McFlurry is currently listed at the McDonald's at 500 N Main St in New Carlisle, OH for $4.99 as of October 2026. This availability is verified from the McDonald's app for this specific store, and limited-time items can differ by location or disappear when the promotion ends.
Is the limited-time Ramyeon McShaker Fries available at McDonald's at 500 N Main St?
Yes. The limited-time Ramyeon McShaker Fries is currently listed at the McDonald's at 500 N Main St in New Carlisle, OH for $3.69 as of October 2026. This availability is verified from the McDonald's app for this specific store, and limited-time items can differ by location or disappear when the promotion ends.
Is the limited-time Saja Boys Breakfast Meal available at McDonald's at 500 N Main St?
Yes. The limited-time Saja Boys Breakfast Meal is currently listed at the McDonald's at 500 N Main St in New Carlisle, OH for $8.79 as of October 2026. This availability is verified from the McDonald's app for this specific store, and limited-time items can differ by location or disappear when the promotion ends.
Is the McDonald's menu at 500 N Main St more expensive than the New Carlisle average?
The Big Mac at this McDonald's is $5.29. The New Carlisle, OH average Big Mac is $5.29, and the US national average is $5.91. Compare individual items above to see how this store ranks.
Why are McDonald's menu prices at 500 N Main St different from other locations?
McDonald's menu prices at 500 N Main St are set by the local franchise owner — not McDonald's corporate. New Carlisle averages $5.29 for a Big Mac — at or below the $5.91 US average. There are 1 McDonald's in New Carlisle — visit our city page to compare them all.
How many items are on the McDonald's menu at 500 N Main St?
This McDonald's at 500 N Main St in New Carlisle, OH has 21 menu items listed above with current app prices. Browse the full menu on this page or compare with other locations in New Carlisle.
When were McDonald's menu prices at 500 N Main St last updated?
Prices for the McDonald's at 500 N Main St in New Carlisle, OH were last verified October 2026. We source data from the McDonald's mobile app. Franchise owners can adjust prices at any time — check back for the latest.
What is there to do near McDonald's at 500 N Main St in New Carlisle?
After enjoying a meal at McDonald's, explore a variety of attractions that cater to all interests, from nature preserves to military history. There are engaging parks, museums, and entertainment centers that make for great family outings or individual adventures. Top nearby spots: National Museum of the U.S. Air Force — This museum showcases a vast collection of aircraft and artifacts, detailing the history of aviation and the Air Force. It's a must-visit for anyone interested in military history and aviation.; Charleston Falls Preserve — A beautiful nature preserve featuring a 37-foot waterfall, scenic hiking trails, and diverse wildlife, perfect for nature lovers and families alike.; Brukner Nature Center — This center offers wildlife exhibits, hiking trails, and educational programs about local flora and fauna, providing a rich experience for nature enthusiasts.; John Bryan State Park — A state park featuring beautiful hiking trails, rock climbing opportunities, and scenic views of the Little Miami River gorge, ideal for outdoor enthusiasts.; Smith Park — A local park featuring playgrounds, walking trails, and picnic areas, perfect for leisurely strolls or family fun..
What McDonald's locations are near 500 N Main St in New Carlisle?
There is 1 McDonald's location within 5 miles of 500 N Main St in New Carlisle, OH: 1. McDonald's at 2133 Dayton Lakeview Rd, New Carlisle, OH 45344 (4.1 mi away) — rated 3.3 out of 5.

MenuPriceTracker vs. Delivery Apps & Other Price Sites

How do these prices compare to what Uber Eats, DoorDash, or Grubhub show?

Uber Eats, DoorDash, Grubhub, and Seamless inflate McDonald's menu prices by 15–30% on top of the in-store price before adding delivery fees, service fees, and tip. The price you see on a delivery app is not what McDonald's charges at the counter. MenuPriceTracker shows the real menu price from the McDonald's app — what you'd actually pay walking into the restaurant or ordering at the kiosk.

Why not just check TripAdvisor for McDonald's prices?

TripAdvisor doesn't track individual McDonald's store prices. Any price information on TripAdvisor is user-submitted, covers only a small fraction of locations, and can be months or years out of date. MenuPriceTracker tracks store-level prices for 9,200+ US McDonald's locations across all 50 states, refreshed monthly from the McDonald's app.

Where does MenuPriceTracker get McDonald's price data?

Prices are collected at the store level from the McDonald's app, covering 9,200+ locations in every US state. Each store's data is refreshed monthly so you see real local prices — not a national estimate, a delivery markup, or crowdsourced guesses. The national average, state averages, and per-city averages on this site are all computed from that same store-level data.

McDonald's 500 N Main St Prices

This McDonald's at 500 N Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344, New Carlisle charges $5.29 for a Big Mac as of October 2026, sourced directly from the McDonald's mobile app. The New Carlisle city average across 1 location is $5.29. The US national average Big Mac price is $5.91.

Limited-time items currently showing at this specific store include Derpy McFlurry for $4.99 , Ramyeon McShaker Fries for $3.69 , Saja Boys Breakfast Meal for $8.79 . These promotional items are verified from the McDonald's app for this location and can vary by store or disappear when the offer ends.

Price Breakdown — Every Item at This Location

Derpy McFlurry
$4.99
State avg: $5.19
$0.20 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $4.99 for Derpy McFlurry. The state average is $5.19.

Ramyeon McShaker Fries
$3.69
State avg: $3.9
$0.21 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $3.69 for Ramyeon McShaker Fries. The state average is $3.9.

Saja Boys Breakfast Meal
$8.79
State avg: $8.47
$0.32 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $8.79 for Saja Boys Breakfast Meal. The state average is $8.47.

20 Pc. Chicken McNuggets
$7.79
State avg: $8.43
$0.64 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $7.79 for 20 Pc. Chicken McNuggets. The state average is $8.43.

Big Arch
$8.59
State avg: $8.7
$0.11 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $8.59 for Big Arch. The state average is $8.7.

Big Arch Large Meal
$12.89
State avg: $13.02
$0.13 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $12.89 for Big Arch Large Meal. The state average is $13.02.

Big Arch Meal
$12.29
State avg: $12.29
Same as state avg

This McDonald's charges $12.29 for Big Arch Meal. The state average is $12.29.

Big Mac
$5.29
State avg: $5.74
$0.45 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $5.29 for Big Mac. The state average is $5.74.

Big Mac Large Meal
$9.99
State avg: $9.79
$0.20 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $9.99 for Big Mac Large Meal. The state average is $9.79.

Big Mac Meal
$8.79
State avg: $8.95
$0.16 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $8.79 for Big Mac Meal. The state average is $8.95.

Cheeseburger
$2.59
State avg: $2.39
$0.20 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $2.59 for Cheeseburger. The state average is $2.39.

Double Cheeseburger
$3.69
State avg: $3.69
Same as state avg

This McDonald's charges $3.69 for Double Cheeseburger. The state average is $3.69.

Filet-O-Fish
$4.99
State avg: $5.15
$0.16 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $4.99 for Filet-O-Fish. The state average is $5.15.

McChicken
$2.49
State avg: $2.62
$0.13 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $2.49 for McChicken. The state average is $2.62.

Medium Coke
$1.79
State avg: $1.62
$0.17 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $1.79 for Medium Coke. The state average is $1.62.

Medium French Fries
$3.19
State avg: $3.37
$0.18 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $3.19 for Medium French Fries. The state average is $3.37.

Medium Latte
$3.79
State avg: $3.72
$0.07 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $3.79 for Medium Latte. The state average is $3.72.

Medium Minute Maid Orange Juice
$2.59
State avg: $3.11
$0.52 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $2.59 for Medium Minute Maid Orange Juice. The state average is $3.11.

Medium Premium Roast Coffee
$1.89
State avg: $1.93
$0.04 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $1.89 for Medium Premium Roast Coffee. The state average is $1.93.

Medium Strawberry Shake
$4.69
State avg: $4.38
$0.31 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $4.69 for Medium Strawberry Shake. The state average is $4.38.

Vanilla Cone
$2.19
State avg: $2.31
$0.12 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $2.19 for Vanilla Cone. The state average is $2.31.

Order Online: 🍔 McDonald's App → 📍 Store Page → Skip the line · Earn rewards

MenuPriceTracker.com is not affiliated with McDonald's Corporation. Prices are aggregated from store-level data and may not reflect current prices at this location.